Hard tack and coffee is not about battles, but rather about how the common union soldiers of the civil war lived in camp and on the march. The sharpshooters found ready employment in the overland campaign, in the trenches of petersburg, and in the fastmoving shenandoah campaign of 1864. Jan 22, 2015 civil war snipers or sharpshooters as they were then called last weekend we went to see the new movie american sniper, a great story that stimulated my thinking about snipers in general and specifically in the american civil war. The 66th illinois veteran volunteer infantry regiment western sharpshooters originally known as birges western sharpshooters and later as the western sharpshooters 14th missouri volunteers, was a specialized regiment of infantry sharpshooters that served in the union army during the american civil war.
Mills aim in the book is to explain what utilitarianism is, to show why it is the. Apr 22, 2016 ever wondered why iron man and captain america are at odds in civil war. Ever wondered why iron man and captain america are at odds in civil war. Just war utilitarianism approach st georges philosophy. Even a full, 500man skirmisher unit armed with ts rifles is going to break in about 5 seconds if even a small infantry brigade charges them, so theyre useless for holding the line. As usual there is a plethora of information about the civil war and i stumbled on the story of jack hinson. False question 2 2 out of 2 points utilitarianism in spite of the problems that arise in the application. The accuracy of german sniper fire in the trenches in world war i provoked the british army to create sniper schools, manuals, and countersniping tactics. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Eccentricity 1863 knowledge of human nature is the beginning and end of political education, but several years of arduous study in the neighborhood of westminster led henry adams to think that knowledge of english human nature had little or no value outside of england. The mid19th century saw the development of optical sights, meaning that the units of sharpshooters raised in the civil war were even more lethal. Well, the thing is, theyre squishy and they require time to rack up those kills.
The happy machine other things matter besides happiness. Sharpshooters of the american civil war 186165 by philip r. In other words, a country would not need a just war cause other than having the right. Sharpshooters of the american civil war 186165 by philip. Must have books on sharpshooters in the american civil war. Instead, it is the story of two small companies of sharpshooters from massachusetts, and their exploits during that war. His celebrated autobiography appeared during the year of his death. A history of the ninth new jersey volunteer infantry in the civil war by edward g. Utilitarianism is a moral theory that advocates actions that promote overall. Raskolnikov and utilitarianism essay 2092 words examples. Commanders at petersburg used them to scout and capture prisoners, and the sharpshooters did much of the fighting in the endless skirmishes of jubal earlys valley campaign. Mills book utilitarianism is a classic exposition and defense of utilitarianism in ethics. Purchase includes free access to book updates online and a free trial membership in the publishers book club where you can select from more than a million books without charge.
Both sides use arguments from both systems of ethics, for instance the proregistration side emphasizes following the law for the sake of the law once the act is passed. What ought to be required of this doctrine,what conditions is it requisite that the doctrine should fulfill, to make good its. Art historian anthony lee posits that the photographic book, as a whole. Copy and paste one of these options to share this book elsewhere. A musthave book for historians, researchers, reenactors, and writers written in 1861 at the direction of the war department and copiously illustrated, this was the book used to train, lead, and maneuver u. May 15, 2004 this paper compares and contrasts the various attributes of two ethical systems, utilitarianism and property rights. The book has the history of the men both union and confederate, the weapons they used often personal rifles that were nongovernment issue, the regiments they composed of, and the targets deadly toll of officers and enlisted during battles, skirmishes. Earley is a lifelong student of the civil war and has personally visited all the major battlefields of the second united states sharpshooters.
Raskolnikov appears to employ the fundamentals of utilitarianism by pitting the negative consequences of murdering his old landlady against the positive benefits that her money would bestow onto society. Mill, utilitarianism 1863 a brief overview of the reading. Civil war snipers or sharpshooters as they were then called. Wow, if anything they seem op from what i have read here. The hundred years war began with two large english victories stemming from tactical innovations. The essay first appeared as a series of three articles published in frasers magazine in 1861 vol. False question 4 2 out of 2 points utilitarianism prescription as opposed to description is the central concern of an engineering ethics course. The book doesnt expand on their time as sharpshooters but i wonder how often whole units were employed like that. Utilitarianism is a work by john stuart mill now brought to you in this new edition of. Link to this page view link to the book embed a mini book reader 1 page 2 pages open to this page. In this video get a look at the philosophy behind civil war. Sharpshooter press me, a one man operation, proudly announces the publication of its first book, sharpshooters 17501900. Civil war snipers or sharpshooters as they were then. Page 14 i must again repeat, what the assailants of utilitarianism seldom have the justice to acknowledge, that the happiness which forms the utilitarian standard of what is right in conduct is not the agents own happiness, but that of all concerned.
Feb 04, 2018 there are many books on the us sharpshooters during the civil war ranging from very basic to very indepth. This week we begin studying normative ethics, and more specifically, the theory of utilitarianism. Divided into fifteen chapters, it covers the early blackpowder muzzle loading riflemen who. The essay first appeared as a series of three articles published in frasers magazine in 1861. John stuart mills book utilitarianism is a classic exposition and defence of utilitarianism in ethics. Buy the confederate whitworth sharpshooters by morrow, john anderson isbn. Jeremy benthams 17481832 principle of utility is open to the objection that it may well sacrifice the rights of the minority for the sake of the happiness of the majority. Recruited as sharpshooters and clothed in distinctive uniforms with green trim, the handpicked regiment of the ninth new jersey volunteer infantry was renowned and admired far and wide. Oct 18, 2002 buy sharpshooters of the american civil war 186165 warrior by katcher, philip, walsh, professor steve isbn. It was attached to the 15th massachusetts infantry to july, 1864, and to the 19th massachusetts infantry to september.
Sharpshooters made a grand record this day combat on the skirmish line at gettysburg on july 3 timothy j. Major plasters book is the history of these elite sharpshooters during the civil war. Batoche books limited 52 eby street south kitchener, ontario n2g 3l1 canada email. Sharpshooters of the american civil war 186165 book. While the union tried to incorporate sharpshooters into special regiments the usss and did specialty recruiting and qualification the confederates used a less formal method of selecting and organizing shooting specialists which in theory gave them a more evenlydistributed capability. Armor letters, 18621863 collection information biographical sketch scope and content note contents cataloging information processed by emily castle 6 july 2005 manuscript and visual collections department william henry smith memorial library indiana historical society 450 west ohio street indianapolis, in 462023269. True question 3 0 out of 2 points utilitarianism act utilitarians permit lying in a situation if doing so will promote the best consequences. Utilitarianism and the greatest good a utilitarianism. Buy utilitarianism by mill, john stuart, sher, george isbn. Mills aim in the book is to explain what utilitarianism is, to show why it is the best.
John stuart mill 18061873, himself a utilitarian, sought to rescue utilitarianism from this. This book is not intended to define the details of battles or depict their leaders. There are many books on the us sharpshooters during the civil war ranging from very basic to very indepth. Dec 16, 2010 just war utilitarianism approach in uncategorized on december 16, 2010 at 1. Civil war is not really a conflict of utilitarianism and deontology, nor do the versions of utilitarianism and deontology accurately capture the set of perspectives at play. Utilitarianism john stuart mill batoche books faculty of social. But both hold equally that morality must be deduced from prin. The 1st company, massachusetts sharpshooters was organized at lynn field and mustered in september 2. His own theory of morality, writes mill in utilitarianism, is grounded in a. Utilitarianism attempts to distinguish between right and wrong by measuring a decision based on its calculated worth. Some of the passages can be long winded, so its not something you can rush through.
The unwritten story of army life published in 1887 by john d. Sep 30, 2014 john stuart mill, a very important philosopher in the 19 th century, is one of the earliest advocates of utilitarianism. Nov, 2005 the sharpshooters found ready employment in the overland campaign, in the trenches of petersburg, and in the fastmoving shenandoah campaign of 1864. Cuban missile crisis discussion ethical dilemmas in wartime vietnam war us japanese war absolutist reasoning. Jun 14, 2011 whether or not anyone owns an ereader, its amazing how many civil war books are free on amazon, all you require is a computer to read them. I have a new favorite civil war book for now anyway. Sharpshooters of the american civil war 186165 warrior. About 1870 he moved to boonville, where he owned several houses. The regiment was intended, raised, and mustered into federal service as the western. Kelleran, a soldier in company i, 20th maine infantry, descended the slopes of big round top, a rocky eminence where his regiment had spent the. Very nice pictures of uniforms and equipment for the confederate and union armies. Utilitarianism and the greatest good a utilitarianism and.
This is the story of these foot soldiers and their experiences, as they lived them. Buy sharpshooters of the american civil war 186165 warrior by katcher, philip, walsh, professor steve isbn. Christopher kent wilson quotes melvilles poem a utilitarian view of the. Mill, first published in a series of articles in frasers magazine in 1861, in book form 1863.
Civil war snipers or sharpshooters as they were then called last weekend we went to see the new movie american sniper, a great story that stimulated my thinking about snipers in general and specifically in the american civil war. Video contains a varying array of those books for more information on civil war. John stuart mill, a very important philosopher in the 19 th century, is one of the earliest advocates of utilitarianism. In 1872 he was a founding stockholder of a home bank in boonville, which became a national bank two years later. Invision employees share their remote work secrets. Divided into fifteen chapters, it covers the early blackpowder muzzle loading riflemen who delivered death from a distance. His utilitarianism was published in 1863, and auguste comte and positivism appeared in 1865. Utilitarianism is the ethical position taken by the vast majority of economists as well as politicians and bureaucrats. The term utilitarian was first adopted by mill in 1823. Named for massachusetts governor john albion andrewwho prevented these two companies from joining the nationalized berdans sharpshooters so that their families could continue to receive state aidthe andrew sharpshooters often transferred from unit to unit as the need for their unique, longrange shooting skills changed. This paper compares and contrasts the various attributes of two ethical systems, utilitarianism and property rights. They had longbows, which could shoot faster and farther than the french, and many more archers than armoured infantry. Sharpshooters of the revolutionary war by eli gindin on prezi. In his essay, selections from utilitarianism, mill defines what the theory is and provides his responses to common misconceptions people have against it.
Question 1 2 out of 2 points utilitarianism if one makes the descriptive observation that most people fail to act in accord with utilitarianism, this by itself undermines the claim that we ought to promote the greatest good for the greatest number of people. Nice detail and focus on accuracy of the accessories used by the soldiers. From 1865 to 1868 mill served as a member of parliament, after which he retired, spending much of his time at avignon, france, where his wife was buried and where he died. Utilitarianism and the greatest good utilitarianism is a formal name for a familiar, and quite common kind of practical reasoning, in which we first decide how to act, and then subsequently justify our choices and actions, by evaluating which of the feasible alternatives is likely to result in the greatest good, or best possible outcome in compar ison.
Robert taylor diary, 18631864 indiana historical society. The chancellorsville campaign illustrated by darius n. Its crazy all the important memoirs have been put into the ereader format by volunteers, and there are a ton which are only a buck or so cw journals and diaries, etc. A passing remark is all that needs be given to the ignorant blunder of supposing that those who stand up for utility as the test of right and wrong, use the term in that. Utilitarianism and the greatest good utilitarianism is a formal name for a familiar, and quite common kind of practical reasoning, in which we first decide how to act, and then subsequently justify our choices and actions, by evaluating which of the feasible alternatives is likely to result in the greatest good, or best possible outcome in compar ison with all the.
Pattern 1853 enfield, henry rifle, spencer repeating rifle, springfield model 1855, sharps rifle, rifles in the american civil war, springfield model 1861. However, upon close examination, several major flaws can be seen with the utilitarian approach. In early may 1863, the army of the potomac was at the height of its power as it bore down on robert e. We need to use our equipment more efficiently to further weaken the enemy, not to kill more civilians utilitarian reasoning. A utilitarian approach is the greatest good for the greatest number. Utilitarianism 7 as well as truth and falsehood, are questions of observation and experience. Oct 30, 2009 sharpshooter press me, a one man operation, proudly announces the publication of its first book, sharpshooters 17501900. Utility, or the greatest happiness principle, states that actions. Just war utilitarianism approach in uncategorized on december 16, 2010 at 1. These highly trained marksmen served in a frontline role and, due to the technological developments of the 1850s, were equipped with weapons that. Utilitarianism, john stuart mill john stuart mills book utilitarianism is a classic exposition and defense of utilitarianism in ethics. When the american civil war 18611865 broke out, both confederate and union experts decided that specialized sharpshooter units should be formed. This book covers the origin, recruitment, training, and battle record of the regiment and features 32 photographs, four battlefield maps, and a regimental roster.
973 1092 268 1530 513 1479 357 1593 1498 163 387 788 833 307 1454 1531 1500 1562 1458 731 279 702 814 948 529 485 19 1029 316 548 331 330